Dupes for Pigmentclar Eye Cream for Dark Circles
by La Roche-Posay · Eye cream
11 products come close enough to call a dupe, best match first.
How the match is scored
A dupe is always the same kind of product — a serum is only compared with serums. Within that, two things are scored and blended.
Ingredient Match compares the two ingredient lists. Lists are ordered by concentration, so an ingredient near the top counts for more than one near the bottom; a dupe has to cover what matters most in the original. It weighs most of all.
Attribute Match compares what the two products are for: the benefits their ingredients are known for, such as hydrating or acne fighting. Those benefits come from the ingredients, not from tests of either product.
Only products scoring 60% or more are listed, at most 50. A match is about the formula on the label: it can't see concentrations the label doesn't print, texture, or how a product feels on your skin.
Dupe #1
La Roche-Posay
Mela B3 Eyes Discoloration Treatment with Melasyl™79% match
87% Attribute Match · 70% Ingredient Match
They share 26 of this product's 36 ingredients (the dupe lists 52).
Both are
- Fragrance-free
- EU-allergen-free
- Alcohol-free
- Paraben-free
- Sulfate-free
- Reef-safe
Both are likely good for
- Hydrating
- Barrier Repair
- Redness Reducing
- Smoothing
- Brightening
- Dark Spots
- Even Tone
- Acne Fighting
- Oil Control
- Pore Refining
- Antioxidant
- Anti-Pollution
- Under-Eye Care
Brand price: USD 44.99 · checked 25 Sept 2026 · on the brand's site
Compare side by side →Dupe #2
They share 13 of this product's 36 ingredients (the dupe lists 40).
Both are
- Fragrance-free
- EU-allergen-free
- Alcohol-free
- Sulfate-free
- Reef-safe
Both are likely good for
- Hydrating
- Barrier Repair
- Redness Reducing
- Smoothing
- Brightening
- Dark Spots
- Even Tone
- Acne Fighting
- Oil Control
- Pore Refining
- Antioxidant
- Anti-Pollution
Brand price: USD 29.99 · checked 5 Oct 2026 · on the brand's site
Compare side by side →Dupe #3
They share 14 of this product's 36 ingredients (the dupe lists 28).
Both are
- Fragrance-free
- EU-allergen-free
- Alcohol-free
- Paraben-free
- Sulfate-free
- Reef-safe
Both are likely good for
- Hydrating
- Barrier Repair
- Redness Reducing
- Smoothing
- Brightening
- Dark Spots
- Even Tone
- Antioxidant
- Anti-Pollution
Brand price: USD 49.99 · checked 25 Sept 2026 · on the brand's site
Compare side by side →Dupe #4
They share 12 of this product's 36 ingredients (the dupe lists 19).
Both are
- Fragrance-free
- EU-allergen-free
- Paraben-free
- Sulfate-free
- Reef-safe
Both are likely good for
- Hydrating
- Barrier Repair
- Smoothing
- Brightening
- Dark Spots
- Acne Fighting
- Oil Control
- Pore Refining
- Antioxidant
- Anti-Pollution
- Under-Eye Care
Brand price: USD 12.99 · checked 26 Sept 2026 · on the brand's site
Compare side by side →Dupe #5
They share 11 of this product's 36 ingredients (the dupe lists 41).
Both are
- Alcohol-free
- Paraben-free
- Sulfate-free
- Reef-safe
Both are likely good for
- Hydrating
- Barrier Repair
- Redness Reducing
- Smoothing
- Brightening
- Dark Spots
- Even Tone
- Acne Fighting
- Oil Control
- Pore Refining
- Antioxidant
- Anti-Pollution
- Under-Eye Care
Brand price: GBP 42.00 · checked 8 Oct 2026 · on the brand's site
Compare side by side →Dupe #6
They share 9 of this product's 36 ingredients (the dupe lists 26).
Both are
- Fragrance-free
- EU-allergen-free
- Alcohol-free
- Paraben-free
- Sulfate-free
- Reef-safe
Both are likely good for
- Hydrating
- Barrier Repair
- Redness Reducing
- Smoothing
- Brightening
- Dark Spots
- Even Tone
- Acne Fighting
- Oil Control
- Pore Refining
- Antioxidant
- Anti-Pollution
- Under-Eye Care
Brand price: USD 19.99 · checked 5 Oct 2026 · on the brand's site
Compare side by side →Dupe #7
First Aid Beauty
Brighten + Glow Eye Cream with Niacinamide61% match
90% Attribute Match · 37% Ingredient Match
They share 15 of this product's 36 ingredients (the dupe lists 50).
Both are
- Fragrance-free
- EU-allergen-free
- Alcohol-free
- Paraben-free
- Sulfate-free
- Reef-safe
Both are likely good for
- Hydrating
- Barrier Repair
- Redness Reducing
- Smoothing
- Brightening
- Dark Spots
- Even Tone
- Acne Fighting
- Oil Control
- Pore Refining
- Antioxidant
- Anti-Pollution
- Under-Eye Care
Brand price: USD 36.00 · checked 26 Sept 2026 · on the brand's site
Compare side by side →Dupe #8
They share 13 of this product's 36 ingredients (the dupe lists 51).
Both are
- Alcohol-free
- Paraben-free
- Sulfate-free
- Reef-safe
Both are likely good for
- Hydrating
- Barrier Repair
- Redness Reducing
- Smoothing
- Brightening
- Dark Spots
- Even Tone
- Acne Fighting
- Oil Control
- Pore Refining
- Antioxidant
- Anti-Pollution
- Under-Eye Care
Brand price: USD 35.00 · checked 8 Oct 2026 · on the brand's site
Compare side by side →Dupe #9
They share 15 of this product's 36 ingredients (the dupe lists 45).
Both are
- Fragrance-free
- EU-allergen-free
- Paraben-free
- Sulfate-free
- Reef-safe
Both are likely good for
- Hydrating
- Barrier Repair
- Smoothing
- Brightening
- Dark Spots
- Oil Control
- Pore Refining
- Antioxidant
- Anti-Pollution
- Under-Eye Care
Brand price: INR 3200.00 · checked 8 Oct 2026 · on the brand's site
Compare side by side →Dupe #10
They share 11 of this product's 36 ingredients (the dupe lists 53).
Both are
- EU-allergen-free
- Alcohol-free
- Paraben-free
- Sulfate-free
- Reef-safe
Both are likely good for
- Hydrating
- Barrier Repair
- Redness Reducing
- Smoothing
- Brightening
- Dark Spots
- Even Tone
- Acne Fighting
- Oil Control
- Pore Refining
- Antioxidant
- Anti-Pollution
- Under-Eye Care
Brand price: USD 43.00 · checked 26 Sept 2026 · on the brand's site
Compare side by side →Dupe #11
They share 16 of this product's 36 ingredients (the dupe lists 50).
Both are
- Fragrance-free
- EU-allergen-free
- Sulfate-free
- Reef-safe
Both are likely good for
- Hydrating
- Barrier Repair
- Smoothing
- Brightening
- Dark Spots
- Acne Fighting
- Oil Control
- Pore Refining
- Antioxidant
- Anti-Pollution
Brand price: USD 22.99 · checked 5 Oct 2026 · on the brand's site
Compare side by side →